Common Verbs That Break the ‘S’ Rule: A Grammar Guide

Mastering English grammar involves understanding various rules and their exceptions. One such rule is the addition of ‘s’ to the base form of verbs in the present simple tense when the subject is a third-person singular pronoun (he, she, it) or a noun that can be replaced by one of these pronouns.

However, certain verbs deviate from this pattern, often causing confusion for English language learners. This article provides a comprehensive guide to these exceptions, exploring their characteristics, usage, and common pitfalls.

Whether you’re a beginner or an advanced learner, understanding these verbs will significantly improve your grammatical accuracy and fluency.

This guide’s comprehensive explanations, examples, and practice exercises are designed to solidify your understanding. By the end of this guide, you’ll be equipped to confidently use these verbs that “break the ‘s’ rule” in various contexts, enhancing your overall command of English grammar and communication skills.

Table of Contents

Defining Verbs That Break the ‘S’ Rule

The “’s’ rule” in English grammar refers to the addition of the suffix ‘-s’ or ‘-es’ to the base form of a verb in the present simple tense when the subject is a third-person singular pronoun (he, she, it) or a noun that can be replaced by one of these pronouns. For instance, we correctly say “He walks to school” or “She eats lunch.” Verbs that “break” this rule are those where the third-person singular form does not follow this standard pattern. These are primarily auxiliary verbs like be (is), have (has), and modal verbs such as can, will, should, must, etc. which do not add an ‘-s’ in the third-person singular.

These verbs are often referred to as irregular verbs in this context, although the term “irregular” is more commonly used to describe verbs with irregular past tense and past participle forms. However, in the context of the present simple tense, these auxiliaries and modals display irregular behavior by not conforming to the standard ‘-s’ rule.

Classification

Verbs that break the ‘s’ rule can be classified into two main categories: auxiliary verbs and modal verbs. Auxiliary verbs, also known as helping verbs, assist the main verb in a sentence to express tense, voice, or mood.

Modal verbs, on the other hand, express necessity, possibility, permission, or ability.

Function

The function of these verbs is crucial in constructing grammatically correct and meaningful sentences. Auxiliary verbs help form different tenses (e.g., “He is running”), while modal verbs add nuance and express different modalities (e.g., “She can swim”). Understanding their function is essential for both comprehension and production of English.

Contexts

These verbs appear in various contexts, from everyday conversations to formal writing. They are fundamental to expressing actions, states, and possibilities. For example, the verb “be” is used to describe states of being (“He is happy”), while modal verbs are used to express obligations (“You must finish your homework”). Their versatility makes them indispensable in the English language.

Structural Breakdown

The structural behavior of verbs that break the ‘s’ rule is unique and contrasts with regular verbs. Regular verbs in the present simple tense follow a consistent pattern: the base form is used for all subjects except the third-person singular, which takes the ‘-s’ or ‘-es’ suffix.

For example: I walk, you walk, he/she/it walks, we walk, they walk.

However, verbs like ‘be,’ ‘have,’ and modal verbs have distinct forms and rules. The verb ‘be’ is particularly irregular, having three forms in the present simple: ‘am’ (for I), ‘is’ (for he/she/it), and ‘are’ (for you/we/they).

The verb ‘have’ changes to ‘has’ only in the third-person singular. Modal verbs, such as ‘can,’ ‘will,’ ‘should,’ ‘must,’ remain unchanged regardless of the subject.

They also do not require an auxiliary verb to form questions or negative sentences, unlike most other verbs.

Let’s examine the structural elements in more detail:

  • ‘Be’ Verb: The most irregular of the bunch, it takes three different forms: am, is, and are.
  • ‘Have’ Verb: It changes to has only in the third-person singular form.
  • Modal Verbs: These verbs remain the same regardless of the subject (e.g., can, could, will, would, shall, should, may, might, must).

Understanding these structural differences is crucial for accurate sentence construction and effective communication.

Types and Categories of Irregular Verbs

As mentioned earlier, verbs that “break the ‘s’ rule” primarily fall into two categories: auxiliary verbs and modal verbs. Each category has its distinct characteristics and functions.

Auxiliary Verbs

Auxiliary verbs, also known as helping verbs, assist the main verb in a sentence. The primary auxiliary verbs are be, do, and have. These verbs help form different tenses, voice, and mood. The auxiliary verbs be and have are the ones that change form in the present simple tense to is and has, respectively, for the third-person singular.

Examples of auxiliary verbs in use:

  • He is running. (present continuous tense)
  • She has finished her work. (present perfect tense)
  • They are going to the store. (future tense)

Modal verbs express possibility, necessity, permission, ability, or obligation. They include verbs like can, could, will, would, shall, should, may, might, and must. Unlike most verbs, modal verbs do not change form based on the subject. They also do not require the auxiliary verb “do” to form questions or negative statements.

Examples of modal verbs in use:

  • He can swim. (ability)
  • She should study. (advice)
  • They must arrive on time. (obligation)
  • It might rain later. (possibility)

Examples of Irregular Verbs

To further illustrate how these verbs break the ‘s’ rule, let’s look at a variety of examples categorized by verb type.

Examples with the Verb “Be”

The verb “be” is the most irregular in the present simple tense, with three different forms: “am,” “is,” and “are.”

The following table shows examples of the verb “be” used with different subjects:

Subject Verb Form Example Sentence
I am I am a student.
You are You are my friend.
He is He is tall.
She is She is happy.
It is It is raining.
We are We are a team.
They are They are ready.
The book is The book is interesting.
The students are The students are learning.
My dog is My dog is playful.
My parents are My parents are supportive.
The weather is The weather is nice today.
The flowers are The flowers are blooming.
The car is The car is new.
The cars are The cars are parked.
The movie is The movie is exciting.
The movies are The movies are popular.
The music is The music is loud.
The songs are The songs are beautiful.
The food is The food is delicious.
The dishes are The dishes are clean.
The house is The house is big.
The houses are The houses are expensive.
The computer is The computer is fast.
The computers are The computers are outdated.

Examples with the Verb “Have”

The verb “have” changes to “has” only in the third-person singular form.

The following table shows examples of the verb “have” used with different subjects:

Subject Verb Form Example Sentence
I have I have a car.
You have You have a book.
He has He has a dog.
She has She has a cat.
It has It has been a long day.
We have We have a plan.
They have They have tickets.
The student has The student has a question.
The students have The students have homework.
My sister has My sister has a new job.
My parents have My parents have a vacation planned.
The company has The company has a new policy.
The employees have The employees have benefits.
The project has The project has a deadline.
The teams have The teams have goals.
The building has The building has an elevator.
The apartments have The apartments have balconies.
The computer has The computer has a virus.
The computers have The computers have updates.
The restaurant has The restaurant has good reviews.
The restaurants have The restaurants have outdoor seating.
The city has The city has many attractions.
The cities have The cities have diverse cultures.
The country has The country has a rich history.
The countries have The countries have trade agreements.

Examples with Modal Verbs

Modal verbs do not change form regardless of the subject.

The following table shows examples of modal verbs used with different subjects:

Subject Modal Verb Example Sentence
I can I can speak English.
You can You can drive a car.
He can He can play the guitar.
She can She can sing well.
It can It can be difficult.
We can We can help you.
They can They can solve the problem.
I will I will go to the party.
You will You will succeed.
He will He will arrive soon.
She will She will call you later.
It will It will be okay.
We will We will support you.
They will They will understand.
I should I should exercise more.
You should You should study harder.
He should He should apologize.
She should She should eat healthy.
It should It should be easy.
We should We should help the poor.
They should They should listen carefully.
I must I must finish this report.
You must You must respect your elders.
He must He must obey the rules.
She must She must be on time.
It must It must be done carefully.
We must We must protect the environment.
They must They must follow the instructions.

Negative and Question Forms

The formation of negative and question forms also highlights how these verbs deviate from the standard ‘s’ rule.

With “Be”:

  • Affirmative: He is happy.
  • Negative: He is not happy. (He isn’t happy.)
  • Question: Is he happy?

With “Have”:

  • Affirmative: She has a car.
  • Negative: She does not have a car. (She doesn’t have a car.)
  • Question: Does she have a car?

With Modal Verbs:

  • Affirmative: They can swim.
  • Negative: They cannot swim. (They can’t swim.)
  • Question: Can they swim?

Usage Rules

Understanding the specific usage rules for these verbs is crucial for accurate and effective communication. Here’s a breakdown of the essential rules:

Rules for the Verb “Be”

  • Use “am” with the subject “I.”
  • Use “is” with third-person singular subjects (he, she, it).
  • Use “are” with second-person singular and plural (you) and first- and third-person plural subjects (we, they).

Example:

  • I am a teacher.
  • He is a doctor.
  • They are students.

Rules for the Verb “Have”

  • Use “have” with all subjects except the third-person singular (he, she, it).
  • Use “has” with third-person singular subjects (he, she, it).

Example:

  • I have a question.
  • She has an answer.
  • We have a plan.
  • Modal verbs do not change form regardless of the subject.
  • Modal verbs are always followed by the base form of the main verb.
  • Modal verbs do not use the auxiliary verb “do” to form questions or negative statements.

Example:

  • He can speak French.
  • They should study.
  • We must arrive on time.

Exceptions and Special Cases

While these rules are generally consistent, there are a few exceptions and special cases to be aware of:

  • “Have to”: While “have” changes to “has” in the third-person singular, “have to” behaves differently in negative and question forms. You typically use “do/does” as an auxiliary verb (e.g., “Does he have to leave early?”).
  • Subjunctive Mood: In certain formal contexts, particularly in clauses expressing wishes, demands, or suggestions, the verb “be” may take the base form “be” regardless of the subject (e.g., “It is essential that he be present”).

Common Mistakes

Learners often make mistakes when using these verbs. Here are some common errors and how to correct them:

Incorrect Correct Explanation
He are a student. He is a student. Use “is” with third-person singular subjects.
She have a car. She has a car. Use “has” with third-person singular subjects.
He cans swim. He can swim. Modal verbs do not take an ‘-s’.
They can to go. They can go. Modal verbs are followed by the base form of the verb without “to.”
Does he has a car? Does he have a car? After “does,” use the base form “have.”
He don’t have time. He doesn’t have time. Use “doesn’t” with third-person singular subjects.
I is going to the store. I am going to the store. Use “am” with the subject “I”.
We is happy. We are happy. Use “are” with the subject “we”.
She musts study. She must study. Modal verbs do not change form.
He should to go. He should go. Modal verbs are followed directly by the base form.

Practice Exercises

Test your understanding with these practice exercises. Fill in the blanks with the correct form of the verb or modal verb.

Exercise 1: Choose the correct form of “be”

Choose the correct form of “be” (am, is, are) to complete the following sentences:

  1. I _____ a teacher.
  2. She _____ a doctor.
  3. They _____ students.
  4. We _____ happy to be here.
  5. It _____ a beautiful day.
  6. You _____ my best friend.
  7. He _____ coming to the party.
  8. The book _____ on the table.
  9. The students _____ in the classroom.
  10. My dog _____ very playful.

Answers:

  1. am
  2. is
  3. are
  4. are
  5. is
  6. are
  7. is
  8. is
  9. are
  10. is

Exercise 2: Choose the correct form of “have”

Choose the correct form of “have” (have, has) to complete the following sentences:

  1. I _____ a car.
  2. She _____ a new job.
  3. They _____ many friends.
  4. We _____ a meeting tomorrow.
  5. He _____ a question for you.
  6. You _____ a beautiful smile.
  7. It _____ been a long day.
  8. The company _____ a new policy.
  9. The students _____ homework to do.
  10. My parents _____ a vacation planned.

Answers:

  1. have
  2. has
  3. have
  4. have
  5. has
  6. have
  7. has
  8. has
  9. have
  10. have

Exercise 3: Choose the correct modal verb

Choose the correct modal verb (can, should, must, will) to complete the following sentences:

  1. I _____ speak English fluently.
  2. You _____ study for the exam.
  3. We _____ arrive on time.
  4. They _____ help you with that.
  5. He _____ be more careful.
  6. She _____ call you later.
  7. It _____ rain tomorrow.
  8. The students _____ listen to the teacher.
  9. My friend _____ come to visit me.
  10. The team _____ win the game.

Answers (Note: Multiple modal verbs might be appropriate depending on the intended meaning):

  1. can
  2. should
  3. must
  4. will/can
  5. should
  6. will
  7. might/could
  8. should/must
  9. will/might/can
  10. should/must/will

Exercise 4: Correct the sentences

Correct the following sentences that contain errors related to the ‘s’ rule:

  1. He are my friend.
  2. She have a dog.
  3. They cans swim well.
  4. I is happy.
  5. We has a plan.
  6. He should to study.
  7. She musts go.
  8. It have been a long day.
  9. You is my best friend.
  10. They is coming to the party.

Answers:

  1. He is my friend.
  2. She has a dog.
  3. They can swim well.
  4. I am happy.
  5. We have a plan.
  6. He should study.
  7. She must go.
  8. It has been a long day.
  9. You are my best friend.
  10. They are coming to the party.

Advanced Topics

For advanced learners, exploring more complex aspects of these verbs can further enhance their understanding and usage.

Subjunctive Mood

The subjunctive mood is used to express wishes, suggestions, demands, or hypothetical situations. In the present subjunctive, the base form of the verb “be” (i.e., “be”) is used regardless of the subject.

This is a deviation from the standard present simple forms.

Examples:

  • It is essential that he be present at the meeting.
  • I suggest that she be given a raise.
  • The doctor recommended that he be admitted to the hospital.

Inversion with Modal Verbs

In formal English, particularly in conditional sentences, modal verbs can be used in inverted constructions without “if.” This involves placing the modal verb at the beginning of the sentence, followed by the subject.

Examples:

  • Should you need any assistance, please contact us. (Instead of: If you should need any assistance…)
  • Were I to know the answer, I would tell you. (Instead of: If I were to know the answer…)

Nuances of Modal Verbs

Modal verbs often have subtle differences in meaning that can significantly impact the overall message. Understanding these nuances is crucial for precise communication.

For example:

  • “Must” expresses a strong obligation or necessity.
  • “Should” expresses a recommendation or advice.
  • “May” expresses possibility or permission.
  • “Might” expresses a weaker possibility.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

  1. Why do some verbs not follow the ‘s’ rule in the present simple tense?
    These verbs, primarily auxiliary verbs like ‘be’ and ‘have,’ and modal verbs, have evolved differently historically and have unique grammatical functions. Their irregularity is a characteristic of their role in forming different tenses, moods, and expressing modalities.
  2. How can I remember which verbs break the ‘s’ rule?
    Focus on the auxiliary verbs ‘be’ and ‘have’ and the modal verbs (can, could, will, would, shall, should, may, might, must). Practice using them in sentences and pay attention to how they are used in different contexts. Repetition and exposure are key to memorization.
  3. What is the difference between “have” and “has”?
    “Have” is used with the subjects I, you, we, and they, as well as plural nouns. “Has” is used exclusively with the third-person singular subjects he, she, it, and singular nouns.
  4. Do modal verbs ever change form?
    No, modal verbs do not change form regardless of the subject. They remain constant across all persons and numbers.
  5. How do I form questions with modal verbs?
    To form questions with modal verbs, simply invert the subject and the modal verb. For example, “Can he swim?” instead of “Does he can swim?”.
  6. What is the negative form of modal verbs?
    The negative form of modal verbs is usually created by adding “not” after the modal verb. For example, “He cannot swim” or “They should not go.” Contractions like “can’t,” “won’t,” and “shouldn’t” are also commonly used.
  7. Is it ever correct to use “be” without “am,” “is,” or “are”?
    Yes, in the subjunctive mood, the base form “be” is used regardless of the subject, especially in formal contexts to express wishes, suggestions, or demands (e.g., “It is important that she be on time”).
  8. Why is the verb “be” so irregular?
    The verb “be” is one of the oldest verbs in the English language and has evolved from multiple sources, resulting in its highly irregular forms. Its variations reflect its fundamental role in expressing existence and states of being.

Conclusion

Understanding verbs that break the ‘s’ rule is crucial for mastering English grammar. These verbs, primarily auxiliary verbs like ‘be’ and ‘have’ and modal verbs, have unique characteristics that set them apart from regular verbs.

By grasping their usage rules and avoiding common mistakes, you can significantly improve the accuracy and fluency of your English.

Remember to practice regularly, pay attention to the contexts in which these verbs are used, and don’t be afraid to ask questions. With consistent effort and a solid understanding of these concepts, you’ll be well on your way to mastering this essential aspect of English grammar.

Keep practicing and you’ll soon find these “rule-breaking” verbs becoming second nature.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top