Verbs That Break the ‘S’ Rule: A Comprehensive Guide

Mastering English grammar involves understanding various verb rules, and one of the most fundamental is the ‘S’ rule for present simple tense. This rule dictates that for third-person singular subjects (he, she, it), the verb typically takes an ‘s’ or ‘es’ ending.

However, several exceptions exist, creating a challenge for English learners. This article dives deep into verbs that don’t follow the ‘S’ rule, providing a comprehensive understanding of their usage, exceptions, and common mistakes.

This guide is perfect for English language learners, students, and anyone looking to refine their grammar skills.

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Definition: Verbs That Don’t Follow the ‘S’ Rule
  3. Structural Breakdown
  4. Types and Categories
  5. Examples
  6. Usage Rules
  7. Common Mistakes
  8. Practice Exercises
  9. Advanced Topics
  10. FAQ
  11. Conclusion

Definition: Verbs That Don’t Follow the ‘S’ Rule

The “S” rule in English grammar primarily applies to verbs in the present simple tense. For most verbs, when the subject is a third-person singular pronoun (he, she, it) or a singular noun, we add an “s” or “es” to the base form of the verb. For example, “He walks,” “She eats,” or “The dog barks.” However, certain verb categories and grammatical structures deviate from this rule. These exceptions are crucial to understand for accurate and fluent English communication.

Verbs that don’t follow this rule typically fall into several categories: modal verbs, auxiliary verbs (in certain contexts), verbs used in the subjunctive mood, and verbs used in the imperative mood. These forms maintain their base form regardless of the subject’s person or number. Recognizing these exceptions prevents grammatical errors and enhances clarity in writing and speech.

Structural Breakdown

The structure of sentences with verbs that don’t follow the ‘S’ rule depends on the specific verb type. Let’s break down the structure for each category:

  • Modal Verbs: Subject + Modal Verb + Base Form of Main Verb (e.g., He can swim.)
  • Auxiliary Verbs (with other verbs): Subject + Auxiliary Verb + Base Form of Main Verb (e.g., They do play.)
  • Subjunctive Mood: Subject + Verb (often suggesting, recommending, etc.) + That + Subject + Base Form of Verb (e.g., I suggest that he be present.)
  • Imperative Mood: Base Form of Verb (understood subject is “you”) (e.g., Open the door.)

Understanding these structures is essential for constructing grammatically correct sentences. The absence of the ‘s’ ending is a key feature that distinguishes these verbs from regular present simple verbs with third-person singular subjects.

Types and Categories

Modal verbs (also known as modal auxiliaries) are a type of auxiliary verb used to express possibility, necessity, permission, ability, or obligation. They always precede the main verb in a sentence and do not change form based on the subject. Common modal verbs include can, could, may, might, must, shall, should, will, and would.

A key characteristic of modal verbs is that they are always followed by the base form of the main verb. This means that even when the subject is third-person singular (he, she, it), the main verb does not take an ‘s’ ending. For instance, we say “He can swim,” not “He cans swim” or “He can swims.”

Auxiliary Verbs

Auxiliary verbs, also known as helping verbs, support the main verb in a sentence to express tense, mood, or voice. The primary auxiliary verbs are be, do, and have. While these verbs can follow the ‘S’ rule in certain contexts (e.g., “He is,” “She does,” “It has“), they do not when used with other verbs in certain constructions.

For example, when using “do” to form questions or negative statements in the present simple, the main verb remains in its base form, even with a third-person singular subject. We say “He does not like” or “Does she understand?” not “He does not likes” or “Does she understands?”.

Irregular Verbs in Specific Contexts

While most irregular verbs follow the ‘S’ rule in the present simple tense, there are instances where they don’t, particularly in specific idiomatic expressions or constructions. These cases are fewer but important to recognize for complete accuracy.

One important example is the verb “be” in the subjunctive mood, which will be discussed in more detail below. In that mood, the verb “be” takes the base form “be” regardless of the subject. For example, “I suggest that he be on time.”

Subjunctive Mood

The subjunctive mood is used to express wishes, suggestions, demands, or hypothetical situations. In modern English, the subjunctive mood is most commonly found in “that” clauses following verbs that express a strong opinion, recommendation, or necessity, such as suggest, recommend, demand, insist, and request. In these clauses, the verb takes its base form, regardless of the subject.

For instance, instead of saying “I suggest that he goes to the doctor,” we use the subjunctive mood and say “I suggest that he go to the doctor.” The verb “go” remains in its base form, even though the subject is “he.” This is a key characteristic of the subjunctive mood.

Imperative Mood

The imperative mood is used to give commands or make requests. In the imperative mood, the verb is always in its base form, and the subject (“you”) is usually implied rather than explicitly stated.

Because the subject is always understood as “you” (second-person), the verb never takes an ‘s’ ending.

For example, instead of saying “You close the door,” we simply say “Close the door.” The verb “close” is in its base form, and the ‘s’ ending is never added in the imperative mood, regardless of who is being spoken to.

Examples

The following table illustrates the use of modal verbs with various subjects, demonstrating that the main verb does not take an ‘s’ ending, even with third-person singular subjects.

Subject Modal Verb Main Verb (Base Form) Sentence
I can swim I can swim.
You should study You should study.
He will arrive He will arrive soon.
She must leave She must leave now.
It may rain It may rain later.
We could help We could help you.
They might understand They might understand the problem.
John can sing John can sing very well.
The cat will sleep The cat will sleep on the sofa.
I would like I would like some coffee.
You must remember You must remember to bring your passport.
He should exercise He should exercise more often.
She can dance She can dance beautifully.
It could be It could be a problem.
We may visit We may visit Paris next year.
They will participate They will participate in the competition.
My friend might call My friend might call tonight.
The students should listen The students should listen to the teacher.
I can understand I can understand Spanish.
You will succeed You will succeed if you try hard.
He may attend He may attend the meeting.
She must finish She must finish her homework.
It should work It should work now.
We can solve We can solve this problem together.
They would appreciate They would appreciate your help.
The team might win The team might win the championship.
I should practice I should practice my English more.

Auxiliary Verb Examples

This table demonstrates the use of the auxiliary verb “do” in questions and negative statements. Notice that the main verb always remains in its base form, regardless of the subject.

Subject Auxiliary Verb (Do) Main Verb (Base Form) Sentence
I do like I do not like coffee.
You do understand Do you understand?
He does want He does not want to go.
She does know Does she know the answer?
It does matter It doesn’t matter.
We do need We do not need any help.
They do agree Do they agree with the plan?
John does play John does not play football.
The cat does eat Does the cat eat fish?
I do remember I do not remember his name.
You do believe Do you believe in ghosts?
He does care He does not care about the consequences.
She does live Does she live in London?
It does seem It does not seem right.
We do have We do not have any questions.
They do think Do they think it’s a good idea?
My friend does work My friend does not work on weekends.
The students do study Do the students study hard?
I do speak I do not speak French.
You do understand Do you understand the instructions?
He does mind He does not mind helping.
She does drive Does she drive to work?
It does hurt It does not hurt anymore.
We do want We do not want to leave.
They do know Do they know the truth?
The team does practice The team does not practice on Mondays.

Subjunctive Mood Examples

The table below illustrates the subjunctive mood, focusing on “that” clauses following verbs of suggestion, recommendation, or demand. Notice that the verb in the “that” clause is always in its base form.

Main Clause Subordinating Conjunction (That) Subjunctive Clause (Subject + Base Form of Verb) Sentence
I suggest that he go I suggest that he go to the doctor.
She recommends that they be She recommends that they be on time.
The doctor insisted that she rest The doctor insisted that she rest for a week.
It is essential that he arrive It is essential that he arrive early.
They demanded that we leave They demanded that we leave immediately.
The rule requires that everyone wear The rule requires that everyone wear a helmet.
I propose that the meeting adjourn I propose that the meeting adjourn.
It is important that she understand It is important that she understand the rules.
He requested that I help He requested that I help him with the project.
The manager suggested that the team collaborate The manager suggested that the team collaborate more effectively.
It is crucial that they understand It is crucial that they understand the implications.
The committee recommended that the proposal be accepted The committee recommended that the proposal be accepted.
I advise that you reconsider I advise that you reconsider your decision.
It is imperative that we act It is imperative that we act quickly.
The law requires that drivers have The law requires that drivers have insurance.
She suggested that he apologize She suggested that he apologize for his behavior.
The teacher recommended that students read The teacher recommended that students read more books.
It is necessary that we prepare It is necessary that we prepare for the exam.
I move that the vote proceed I move that the vote proceed immediately.
The contract stipulates that all parties agree The contract stipulates that all parties agree to the terms.
They urged that she apply They urged that she apply for the job.
It is vital that they understand It is vital that they understand the importance of this matter.
The regulations state that all employees attend The regulations state that all employees attend the training.
I insist that you stay I insist that you stay for dinner.

Imperative Mood Examples

This table showcases examples of the imperative mood. Note that the verb is always in its base form, and the subject “you” is implied.

Verb (Base Form) Sentence (Command/Request)
Open Open the door.
Close Close the window.
Listen Listen carefully.
Be Be quiet.
Do Do your homework.
Come Come here.
Go Go away.
Sit Sit down.
Stand Stand up straight.
Read Read the instructions.
Write Write your name.
Speak Speak clearly.
Think Think before you act.
Look Look at the picture.
Wait Wait for me.
Help Help me with this.
Try Try again.
Remember Remember to call me.
Bring Bring your books tomorrow.
Answer Answer the question.
Clean Clean your room.
Turn Turn off the lights.
Pay Pay attention.
Ask Ask for help.
Call Call me later.
Explain Explain the problem.
Show Show me your work.

Irregular Verbs in Specific Contexts

This table provides examples of irregular verbs that do not follow the ‘S’ rule in the subjunctive mood.

Main Clause Subordinating Conjunction (That) Subjunctive Clause (Subject + Base Form of Verb) Sentence
I suggest that he be I suggest that he be on time.
It is important that she be It is important that she be prepared.
They requested that we be They requested that we be informed.
The requirement is that it be The requirement is that it be completed by Friday.
She recommended that the door be She recommended that the door be locked.
The contract stipulates that all information be The contract stipulates that all information be kept confidential.
The judge ordered that he be The judge ordered that he be released immediately.
The proposal suggests that it be The proposal suggests that it be approved promptly.
The rule requires that every student be The rule requires that every student be present.

Usage Rules

Modal verbs have specific rules that govern their usage:

  • Modal verbs are always followed by the base form of the main verb.
  • Modal verbs do not take an ‘s’ ending in the third-person singular.
  • Modal verbs do not have infinitive or past participle forms.
  • Modal verbs are used to express possibility, necessity, permission, ability, or obligation.

For example, “He can speak English” is correct, while “He cans speak English” or “He can speaks English” are incorrect.

Auxiliary Verb Rules

The auxiliary verb “do” has specific rules when used with other verbs:

  • When forming questions or negative statements in the present simple, use “do” or “does” (for third-person singular).
  • The main verb remains in its base form, regardless of the subject.
  • “Do” is not used with modal verbs.

For example, “Does she like pizza?” is correct, while “Does she likes pizza?” is incorrect.

Subjunctive Mood Rules

The subjunctive mood has specific rules for its usage:

  • The subjunctive mood is used to express wishes, suggestions, demands, or hypothetical situations.
  • In “that” clauses following verbs of suggestion, recommendation, or demand, the verb takes its base form.
  • The subjunctive mood is less common in modern English but is still important in formal writing and speech.

For example, “I suggest that he be present” is correct, while “I suggest that he is present” is incorrect (in formal contexts).

Imperative Mood Rules

The imperative mood has simple rules:

  • The verb is always in its base form.
  • The subject (“you”) is usually implied.
  • Used to give commands or make requests.

For example, “Close the door” is correct, while “Closes the door” is incorrect.

Common Mistakes

One of the most common mistakes is adding an ‘s’ to the main verb after a modal verb. For example:

  • Incorrect: He can swims.
  • Correct: He can swim.

Another common mistake is using the indicative mood instead of the subjunctive mood in “that” clauses. For example:

  • Incorrect: I suggest that he is on time.
  • Correct: I suggest that he be on time.

A further common error involves adding ‘s’ to the imperative form of the verb:

  • Incorrect: Opens the door.
  • Correct: Open the door.

Also, forgetting to use “do/does” in questions and negative sentences can lead to errors:

  • Incorrect: He not like it.
  • Correct: He does not like it.

Practice Exercises

Exercise 1: Modal Verbs

Fill in the blanks with the correct modal verb and the base form of the verb in parentheses.

Question Answer
1. He _______ (speak) English fluently. (can) 1. He can speak English fluently.
2. You _______ (study) for the exam. (should) 2. You should study for the exam.
3. They _______ (arrive) soon. (will) 3. They will arrive soon.
4. She _______ (leave) now. (must) 4. She must leave now.
5. It _______ (rain) later. (may) 5. It may rain later.
6. We _______ (help) you. (could) 6. We could help you.
7. I _______ (like) some coffee. (would) 7. I would like some coffee.
8. You _______ (remember) to bring your passport. (must) 8. You must remember to bring your passport.
9. He _______ (exercise) more often. (should) 9. He should exercise more often.
10. She _______ (dance) beautifully. (can) 10. She can dance beautifully.

Exercise 2: Auxiliary Verbs

Rewrite the following sentences using the auxiliary verb “do” to form questions or negative statements.

Question Answer
1. I like coffee. (negative) 1. I do not like coffee.
2. You understand? (question) 2. Do you understand?
3. He wants to go. (negative) 3. He does not want to go.
4. She knows the answer? (question) 4. Does she know the answer?
5. It matters. (negative) 5. It doesn’t matter.
6. We need any help. (negative) 6. We do not need any help.
7. They agree with the plan? (question) 7. Do they agree with the plan?
8. John plays football. (negative) 8. John does not play football.
9. The cat eats fish? (question) 9. Does the cat eat fish?
10. I remember his name. (negative) 10. I do not remember his name.

Exercise 3: Subjunctive Mood

Rewrite the following sentences using the subjunctive mood where appropriate.

Question Answer
1. I suggest that he goes to the doctor. 1. I suggest that he go to the doctor.
2. She recommends that they are on time. 2. She recommends that they be on time.
3. The doctor insisted that she rests for a week. 3. The doctor insisted that she rest for a week.
4. It is essential that he arrives early. 4. It is essential that he arrive early.
5. They demanded that we left immediately. 5. They demanded that we leave immediately.
6. The rule requires that everyone wears a helmet. 6. The rule requires that everyone wear a helmet.
7. I propose that the meeting adjourns. 7. I propose that the meeting adjourn.
8. It is important that she understands the rules. 8. It is important that she understand the rules.
9. He requested that I helped him with the project. 9. He requested that I help him with the project.
10. The manager suggested that the team collaborates more effectively. 10. The manager suggested that the team collaborate more effectively.

Exercise 4: Imperative Mood

Rewrite the following sentences in the imperative mood.

Question Answer
1. You open the door. 1. Open the door.
2. You close the window. 2. Close

the window.
3. You listen carefully. 3. Listen carefully.
4. You be quiet. 4. Be quiet.
5. You do your homework. 5. Do your homework.
6. You come here. 6. Come here.
7. You go away. 7. Go away.
8. You sit down. 8. Sit down.
9. You stand up straight. 9. Stand up straight.
10. You read the instructions. 10. Read the instructions.

Advanced Topics

Nuances of the Subjunctive Mood

The subjunctive mood, while not as prevalent in modern English as it once was, still carries significant weight in formal writing and certain idiomatic expressions. One of the nuances lies in its ability to convey a sense of urgency, importance, or hypotheticality that other moods might not capture as effectively.

For instance, consider the difference between “It is important that he is here” and “It is important that he be here.” While the first sentence is grammatically correct in the indicative mood, the second, using the subjunctive, implies a stronger sense of necessity or obligation. The subjunctive suggests that his presence is not just important, but crucial or required.

Another nuance is the use of the subjunctive in fixed expressions such as “God save the Queen” or “Be that as it may.” These expressions retain the subjunctive form even though the mood has largely disappeared from everyday speech.

Advanced Modal Verb Usage

Modal verbs, beyond their basic functions of expressing possibility, necessity, and ability, can also convey subtle shades of meaning depending on the context and the speaker’s intent. Understanding these nuances is key to mastering advanced English communication.

For example, “must” can express both obligation and deduction. “You must finish your work” conveys obligation, while “He must be tired” expresses a logical deduction based on available evidence. Similarly, “would” can express a polite request (“Would you mind closing the door?”) or a hypothetical situation (“If I had the money, I would travel the world”).

Furthermore, the use of modal verbs in combination with perfect infinitives (e.g., “should have,” “could have,” “would have”) allows speakers to express regret, speculation about the past, or missed opportunities. “I should have studied harder” expresses regret, while “He could have won the race” speculates about a past possibility.

FAQ

Why don’t modal verbs follow the ‘S’ rule?

Modal verbs are auxiliary verbs, and auxiliary verbs do not change form based on the subject. They are always followed by the base form of the main verb.

When should I use the subjunctive mood?

Use the subjunctive mood to express wishes, suggestions, demands, or hypothetical situations, especially in “that” clauses following verbs of suggestion, recommendation, or demand.

Is the subjunctive mood common in modern English?

The subjunctive mood is less common in modern English than it once was but is still important in formal writing and speech.

How can I identify the imperative mood?

The imperative mood is used to give commands or make requests. The verb is always in its base form, and the subject (“you”) is usually implied.

What are some common mistakes to avoid?

Avoid adding an ‘s’ to the main verb after a modal verb, using the indicative mood instead of the subjunctive mood in “that” clauses, and adding ‘s’ to the imperative form of the verb.

Conclusion

Mastering verbs that break the ‘S’ rule is essential for accurate and fluent English communication. By understanding the categories of verbs that don’t follow this rule—modal verbs, auxiliary verbs, verbs in the subjunctive mood, and verbs in the imperative mood—and practicing their usage, you can avoid common mistakes and enhance your overall command of English grammar.

Remember to pay attention to context and meaning, and don’t hesitate to review the rules and examples provided in this guide. With consistent effort and attention to detail, you can confidently navigate these grammatical nuances and express yourself with clarity and precision.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top